Family businesses are unique assets, carrying economic potential and the legacy and dreams of multiple generations. The closeness of family members sharing the management and leadership of a business can bring many benefits, such as trust and mutual understanding. However, this same proximity can also be a source of tensions and disputes, especially when strategic decisions, such as succession planning, need to be made.
Succession is one of the most delicate moments for the continuity of a family business, as it involves transitioning roles and responsibilities that impact both the company’s structure and personal relationships. Disagreements over who should take the lead, differing visions for the business’s future, and emotional issues tied to authority and recognition are common sources of conflict during this process. Ignoring or downplaying these issues can compromise both the workplace environment and familial bonds, jeopardizing the company’s stability and the family’s well-being.
This article explores how to recognize and manage the main types of family conflicts to ensure a smooth and successful succession. We will delve into practical strategies and tools to help preserve the company’s integrity and strengthen relationships among those involved, ensuring the business continues to thrive while safeguarding the family legacy.
1. Types of Conflicts in Family Businesses
To prevent family conflicts from negatively impacting management and succession, it is essential to understand the different types of conflicts that can arise:
Task Conflicts: These involve disagreements over the company’s goals and objectives. When managed well, such conflicts can lead to productive discussions that improve business strategies, making the company more resilient and aligned with market demands.
Process Conflicts: These center on differences regarding how tasks and activities should be executed. Such conflicts may arise when roles and responsibilities are not clearly defined or when operational processes are disputed. These issues can be minimized through the creation of a detailed organizational chart and the definition of roles and workflows.
Relationship Conflicts: These are the most sensitive and often the most destructive types of conflicts. They stem from personal resentments, rivalries, and hostilities among family members. Such disputes are often rooted in unresolved issues that eventually affect cohesion and organizational effectiveness. Addressing emotional and relational conflicts promptly is critical to ensuring they do not hinder the company’s growth.
2. Corporate Governance to Prevent Conflicts
Corporate governance in family businesses provides a framework to regulate interactions, fostering transparency and security for all parties. Specific governance tools are highly effective in preventing and resolving conflicts:
Family Council: A family council is a formal forum where matters related to the business and family are discussed. It provides family members with an opportunity to address concerns and expectations in a structured manner, reducing the likelihood of conflicts during daily operations. This council also serves as a space to align long-term goals and resolve disagreements diplomatically.
Family Constitution: This document establishes rules and policies for key business issues, including family member hiring, compensation, succession, and profit-sharing. A family constitution can reduce conflicts by setting clear and fair expectations for all parties, contributing to the company’s stability.
Succession Planning: The absence of a clear and well-structured leadership transition plan can create uncertainties and disputes among family members. A succession plan is essential for ensuring a smooth and peaceful transition, especially when developed transparently and involving multiple family generations.
3. The Role of Communication in Conflict Management
In family businesses, open and respectful communication is the cornerstone for preventing and resolving conflicts. Regular and honest dialogue prevents misunderstandings from escalating into larger problems. Effective communication practices include:
Regular Meetings: Frequent meetings are essential for aligning family members on the company’s status and future plans. These gatherings should be formal and structured, with a predefined agenda that allows everyone to express their opinions and be heard. Feedback meetings are also useful for adjusting actions and strategies, fostering continuous dialogue.
Generational Cohorts: In some businesses, it can be helpful to hold meetings specifically for members of different generations. This approach allows each group to discuss their perspectives, aspirations, and concerns in a safe space, fostering mutual understanding between generations and avoiding misunderstandings.
External Facilitators: An external facilitator can be invaluable in critical moments, especially when there are longstanding disputes or significant differences of opinion. Such professionals provide an impartial perspective and help mediate dialogue effectively, ensuring all voices are heard.
According to Rafael Perillo, an expert in Law and Management with extensive experience in resolving family business conflicts, an external facilitator plays a crucial role in guiding discussions impartially and constructively, especially in complex situations. “The facilitator, with their expertise in mediation and family dynamics, acts as a neutral party, helping to identify points of divergence and build bridges for understanding,” Perillo explains. “Moreover, the facilitator creates a safe environment for expressing feelings and perspectives, essential for overcoming conflicts and strengthening family bonds,” he adds.
4. The Role of Consultants and Mediators
For complex or deeply rooted conflicts, seeking assistance from consultants specializing in family businesses can be advantageous. These professionals offer an external perspective and can identify solutions that may not be apparent to family members. Additionally, they help implement governance practices and mediate discussions, facilitating conflict resolution and promoting a more harmonious environment.
External mediators can contribute both in specific instances, to resolve particular disputes, and continuously, by improving communication and collaboration among family members.
5. The Importance of External Professionals on the Board
The inclusion of external professionals on the board of directors is an increasingly common practice in family businesses. These board members bring expertise, market experience, and an impartial perspective, aiding the company in making data-driven decisions based on best practices.
External professionals promote a culture of meritocracy and reduce the likelihood of biased decisions influenced by personal issues, a crucial consideration in family businesses. Their presence exemplifies structured governance and fosters an environment that values professionalization.
6. Developing a Culture of Respect and Transparency
For a family business to thrive across generations, cultivating an organizational culture that values mutual respect and transparency is crucial. Family members should be encouraged to understand and appreciate the roles and contributions of their relatives, recognizing that the business’s success depends on collective effort and adherence to shared values.
A culture of respect and transparency strengthens family bonds and builds trust among members, essential for the company’s longevity. Furthermore, it promotes honesty and commitment, fundamental values for ensuring the business’s continuity.
Conclusion
Succession in a family business requires preparation, communication, and the implementation of governance mechanisms that foster transparency and fairness.
The challenges of a family business extend beyond standard management difficulties, as they involve emotional ties, memories, and often a heritage of values and ideals passed down through generations. Succession is a critical moment demanding careful planning, dialogue, and solid governance to prevent natural disagreements from escalating into harmful conflicts for both the family and the business.
Formal structures like family councils and constitutions help create a predictable and organized environment for addressing delicate succession issues. These tools not only establish clear guidelines for handling operational problems but also provide a platform for family members to discuss expectations and challenges transparently and respectfully. Additionally, support from external mediators and consultants can be vital for maintaining impartiality, especially when dealing with longstanding disagreements or personal rivalries. An external perspective enables objective and constructive solutions, fostering a smoother succession process.
Finally, building an organizational culture rooted in respect and transparency is essential for the long-term success of family businesses. When all involved understand that the business’s success is directly tied to family cohesion, the commitment to preserving the legacy strengthens. Continuous communication, valuing each generation’s contributions, and adopting governance practices ensure not only the business’s continuity but also the reinforcement of familial bonds. This approach keeps the family legacy alive and resilient, ready to face the challenges of a dynamic and competitive market.
About the author: Márcio Teixeira is a professional with vast experience in management and business strategies, with a solid background in Business Management Technology. His career includes decades of experience in leadership roles, where he acquired deep knowledge about the challenges that involve business dynamics and interpersonal relationships, especially in family contexts.
Throughout his career, Márcio has observed closely how family conflicts can impact organizational health and business continuity. This practical experience, coupled with his expertise in strategic planning, allows him to address the topic with authority, offering valuable insights on how to align personal and business interests to ensure a successful succession.
In the article “Family Conflicts: How to Prevent Them from Hindering the Succession of Your Business”, Márcio shares his pragmatic vision and practical solutions to minimize family friction, promoting an environment of dialogue, mutual respect and structured planning. His approach reflects the commitment to the sustainability of family businesses and the construction of a lasting legacy.
References
- Gersick, K. E., Davis, J. A., Hampton, M. M., & Lansberg, I. (1997). Generation to Generation: Life Cycles of the Family Business. Harvard Business Review Press.
- Poza, E. J., & Daugherty, M. S. (2013). Family Business. South-Western Cengage Learning.
- Lansberg, I. (1999). Succeeding Generations: Realizing the Dream of Families in Business. Harvard Business School Press.
- Handler, W. C. (1990). Succession in Family Firms: A Mutual Role Adjustment between Entrepreneur and Next-generation Family Members. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 15(1), 37–51.
- Dyer, W. G. Jr. (1986). Cultural Change in Family Firms: Anticipating and Managing Business and Family Transitions. Jossey-Bass.
- Uecker-Mercado, H., & Walker, M. (2012). The Value of Family Business Governance. Journal of Family Business Strategy, 3(3), 147–158.
- Tagiuri, R., & Davis, J. A. (1996). Bivalent Attributes of the Family Firm. Family Business Review, 9(2), 199–208.
- Astrachan, J. H., & Shanker, M. C. (2003). Family Businesses’ Contribution to the U.S. Economy: A Closer Look. Family Business Review, 16(3), 211–219.
