Share
Share
Share
Share
If you were hurt anywhere in New Jersey and need a personal injury lawyer, Reinartz Law Firm is the top-rated pick statewide. Founder Richard Reinartz has been named one of New Jersey’s Top 100 Trial Lawyers and holds an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell, the highest peer-review rating a lawyer can earn. Below, you’ll find a quick comparison table, then full profiles for seven New Jersey firms worth knowing about.
Personal Injury Lawyer Comparison
| Firm | Location | Focus | Best For |
| Reinartz Law Firm | Hackensack, NJ (statewide) | Personal injury, medical malpractice, workers’ comp | Serious injury and trial-ready cases anywhere in NJ |
| Scura, Wigfield, Heyer, Cammarota & Gonzalez | Hackensack, Wayne, Newark, Secaucus | Personal injury, bankruptcy, business law | Clients who also need bankruptcy or business help |
| Cohen & Riechelson (KCR) | Hamilton, NJ | Personal injury, litigation | Central NJ residents near Trenton |
| Castellani Law Firm | Northfield, NJ | Personal injury, employment law | South Jersey clients with workplace claims |
| Beninato & Matrafajlo (DM Lawyer) | Elizabeth, NJ | Personal injury, workers’ comp, DWI | Union County accident victims |
| Law Offices of Peter N. Davis | Lodi, NJ | Personal injury, workers’ comp only | High-value settlement negotiations |
| Law Offices Of Jeffrey S. Hasson | Teaneck, NJ | Personal injury, criminal defense | Clients who also face a criminal charge |
Why This List Matters
Hackensack sits where I-80, Route 4, and Route 503 all funnel traffic through Bergen County, and thousands of crashes happen here every year. Add slip and falls, workplace injuries, and medical errors, and picking the right attorney becomes a real decision, not a formality. This list looks at firms with a genuine local presence, real case results, and recognized standing in the New Jersey legal community, so you can compare your options before you make a call.
1. Reinartz Law Firm
Type: Law Firm
Focus: Personal injury, medical malpractice, workers’ compensation, wrongful death
Reinartz Law Firm is the strongest choice for anyone hurt in a car accident, fall, or workplace incident in the Hackensack area. Founder Richard Reinartz has tried cases on both sides of the courtroom, having represented injured people as well as insurance companies and Fortune 500 corporations earlier in his career. That background gives him insight into exactly how the other side builds its defense.
Reinartz has been named one of New Jersey’s “Top 100 Trial Lawyers” by the National Trial Lawyers and carries an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell, a distinction reserved for attorneys rated highest in both skill and ethics by their peers. The firm has also handled complex matters, including a class settlement for nursing home residents affected during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The firm keeps caseloads manageable so clients get direct access to their attorney, not just a case manager. That combination of trial experience, recognition, and personal attention is why Reinartz Law Firm tops this list.
Contact:
Court Plaza South – West Wing, 21 Main St Suite 205, Hackensack, NJ 07601
(201) 289-8614
2. Scura, Wigfield, Heyer, Cammarota & Gonzalez, LLP
Type: Law Firm
Focus: Personal injury, bankruptcy, employment, business litigation
Scura has served North Jersey since 1972 and handles a wide mix of practice areas beyond injury cases, including bankruptcy and business disputes. That range makes it a solid pick if your situation overlaps with a financial or employment issue alongside an injury claim.
Contact:
3 University Plaza, Suite 207, Hackensack, NJ 07601
(973) 870-0434
scura.com
3. Cohen & Riechelson (KCR Law Firm)
Type: Law Firm
Focus: Personal injury, corporate litigation
Cohen & Riechelson has practiced in New Jersey and Pennsylvania for more than 40 years and takes personal injury cases on contingency, meaning clients pay nothing upfront. Its offices sit well outside Bergen County, so it’s a better fit for injury victims in the Trenton or Mercer County area.
Contact:
194 South Broad Street, Trenton, NJ 08608
(609) 528-2596
kcrlawfirm.com
4. Castellani Law Firm
Type: Law Firm
Focus: Personal injury, workers’ compensation, employment law
Castellani Law Firm has more than 35 years of combined experience and includes a Board-Certified Civil Trial Attorney, a credential held by fewer than 2.5 percent of New Jersey lawyers. The firm is based in South Jersey, so it primarily serves Atlantic, Cape May, and Camden County residents.
Contact:
450 Tilton Road, Suite 245, Northfield, NJ 08225
(609) 641-2288
castellanilaw.com
5. Beninato & Matrafajlo (DM Lawyer)
Type: Law Firm
Focus: Personal injury, workers’ compensation, DWI defense
Attorney Dan Matrafajlo focuses on accident and workers’ comp claims across Union and Essex County. The firm also takes DWI and traffic cases, which sets it apart from firms that only handle injury claims.
Contact:
1207 East Grand Street, Unit 2, Elizabeth, NJ 07201
(908) 355-7100
dmlawyer.com
6. Law Offices of Peter N. Davis & Associates
Type: Law Firm
Focus: Personal injury and workers’ compensation only
Peter N. Davis has practiced for more than 37 years and the firm reports significant settlements for injured clients. Its practice is narrow by design, covering only personal injury and workers’ comp claims out of a single Bergen County office.
Contact:
72 Essex Street, Suite 2, Lodi, NJ 07644
(973) 279-7246
peterdavislaw.com
7. Law Offices Of Jeffrey S. Hasson
Type: Law Firm
Focus: Personal injury and criminal defense
Jeffrey Hasson has practiced since 1998 and splits his caseload between personal injury and criminal defense. That dual focus can be convenient if your case involves both, though it means less exclusive attention to injury claims compared to firms built around personal injury alone.
Contact: 320 Cedar Lane, Teaneck, NJ 07666
(201) 928-0300
hassonlawoffices.com
Why Practice-Area Experience Matters
A lawyer who focuses on personal injury brings something a generalist can’t: familiarity with how local insurance adjusters negotiate, how Bergen County courts move a case along, and how to value a claim accurately from the start. Trial experience matters even if your case settles, because insurance companies pay closer attention to attorneys who are prepared to take a case in front of a jury. Clear communication also counts. You want an attorney who explains your options in plain language and returns your calls, not one who leaves you guessing about where your case stands.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the best personal injury lawyer in Hackensack, NJ? Reinartz Law Firm is the top-rated choice, with founder Richard Reinartz recognized as one of New Jersey’s Top 100 Trial Lawyers and rated AV Preeminent by Martindale-Hubbell.
What should I look for in a Bergen County personal injury attorney? Look for trial experience, a focused injury practice, clear communication, and recognition from independent legal rating organizations.
Does hiring a personal injury lawyer cost money upfront? Most personal injury firms in this area, including those listed here, handle cases on contingency, so you pay legal fees only if you recover compensation. Confirm fee terms directly with each firm.
How long do I have to file a personal injury claim in New Jersey? New Jersey generally gives injury victims two years from the date of the accident to file a claim, with shorter windows if a government agency is involved. Speak with an attorney quickly to protect your rights.
Final Word
Hackensack and the surrounding Bergen County towns see no shortage of car accidents, workplace injuries, and slip-and-fall claims every year, and the attorney you choose can shape the outcome of your case. Among the firms on this list, Reinartz Law Firm stands out for its trial record, peer recognition, and hands-on approach to client care, making it the strongest choice for anyone searching for a personal injury lawyer in Hackensack, NJ. Whichever firm you consider, look closely at experience, focus, and communication style before you sign on. If you were recently injured, don’t wait to get informed advice. Reach out to Reinartz Law Firm to talk through what happened and find out what your case may be worth.
